#Becomingeducational Yes – it’s the summer – but…
We found this post on the difficulties of the Literature Review really helpful in the very practical way it helps PhD students unpack examiner comments and re-shape a Literature Review.
We especially like – her answers when examiners ask doctoral researchers to change their literature review to show how they are “located” in the text.
Specifically referring to:
What key concepts and interpretations you have taken from the literature to inform the design of the study.
What key concepts and interpretations from the literatures you will use to analyse your data.
What general approach to the topic that you have taken and where your work sits within the field.
One to share with all our PhD students.
Sandra & Tom
Yes, some examiners do ask doctoral researchers to change their literature review to show how they are “located” in the text.
OK, let’s pretend this is you. What do those pesky examiners mean exactly?
At one level this is a simple task. You are being asked to say
What key concepts and interpretations you have taken from the literature to inform the design of the study. Because no one does a project entirely from scratch – we all use other people’s work as building blocks – we have to specify exactly what wehaveborrowed. And you are also being asked to show how you have used concepts, approaches and/or interpretations. (This may well mean for instance that you have to refer back to the literatures when the methods are being explained. For instance, surveys almost always use literatures that have been introduced and explained earlier.)
What key concepts…
View original post 869 more words